Keep staff safe first, then collect what the police need. A shop can ask a suspected shoplifter to pay or hand the goods back, ask them to leave, report the theft to the police with CCTV, ban them from the premises and, in some cases, claim its losses through civil recovery. Staff can make a citizen's arrest only under narrow conditions, and staff should not search a bag unless the person agrees.
This page is general information about the law in England, Wales and Scotland, not legal advice. If your shop is part of a chain or uses a security contractor, follow their policy on shoplifting first.
| Option | What the law or police guidance says | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Ask them to pay or leave | Police guidance says retailers may ask anyone to leave private premises at any time | If they refuse and there are threats, violence or disorder, call the police |
| Citizen's arrest | England and Wales: section 24A of PACE, four conditions. Scotland: common law, a stricter test | A wrongful arrest can lead to a claim against whoever made it, and staff can get hurt |
| Search their bag | Only with the person's consent; in England and Wales, search on arrest is a police power | If they say no, wait for the police |
| Report it | 999 if it is happening, someone is in danger or the suspect is held; otherwise online or 101 | Save the CCTV before the recorder overwrites it |
| Ban them | A written banning notice; shared "banned from one, banned from all" schemes | Breaking a ban is not normally a crime on its own |
| Civil recovery | Claim losses and costs, even without a conviction | Costs must be proved, and only a court can make them pay |
Should staff tackle a shoplifter?
Not if it puts anyone at risk, and police and trade guidance for shops says so first. Cleveland Police's 2026 retail crime toolkit lists "Ensure staff safety comes first" as the first thing to do when a theft happens. The Association of Convenience Stores warns that encountering shop thieves "can often result in violence and verbal abuse towards shopworkers", and its crime guidance tells staff to put their safety first and keep a safe distance.
The National Business Crime Centre (NBCC) says most shoplifters will not pose a risk to staff, but people affected by mental health issues, drink or drugs, and determined thieves may. Nobody can tell which is which in the few seconds at the door. So keep it to a polite question from a safe distance, and let the person go if it turns nasty. The stock can be replaced. The footage and the report are what lead to an arrest later.
Can shop staff make a citizen's arrest?
Yes, in England and Wales, but the power is narrower than most people think. Section 24A of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE) lets anyone who is not a police officer arrest someone without a warrant. Shop staff and security guards get nothing extra: the Security Industry Authority (SIA) says security operatives have the same powers as any other citizen. All of these have to be true:
- The offence is indictable. In England and Wales that includes either-way offences, and theft is one, with a maximum of seven years in custody.
- You saw it or have good grounds. The person is in the act, or you have reasonable grounds to suspect they are. After the event, an offence must actually have been committed, and you must have reasonable grounds to suspect this person did it.
- The arrest is necessary. You have reasonable grounds to believe it is needed to stop them hurting themselves or someone else, being hurt, causing loss of or damage to property, or making off before a police officer can take responsibility for them.
- The police cannot do it instead. It appears to you that it is not reasonably practicable for an officer to make the arrest.
The second condition is where shops get caught out. Section 24A(1) covers someone you see in the act, or reasonably suspect is in the act. Section 24A(2), which covers arrests after the event, applies only "where an indictable offence has been committed". If staff stop someone after the event who turns out to have paid at another till, there was no offence, and that subsection gives no cover. SIA training content warns that a false arrest can lead to civil or criminal action against the person who made it, and describes arrest as a last resort.
Any force has to be reasonable. The SIA puts it as force that is "necessary to the circumstances and proportionate to the threat", and adds that incapacitant sprays are illegal in the UK. Cleveland Police's toolkit says physical intervention should only be considered where it is lawful, necessary and proportionate, and that staff should follow their own policies and procedures.
What about thefts under £200? Stealing goods worth £200 or less from a shop is "low-value shoplifting" under section 22A of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, tried only in the magistrates' court unless an adult chooses the Crown Court. The value is the shop's selling price, and several thefts charged together are added up. The lower court does not remove the citizen's arrest power: the explanatory notes to the 2014 Act that created the rule say a power of arrest by someone other than a police officer, giving a store detective as the example, stays available. The Crime and Policing Act 2026 repeals section 22A altogether. On 8 November 2026, legislation.gov.uk still showed that repeal as not yet in force.
If staff do arrest someone, the SIA's training content sets out what comes next: tell the person they are under arrest, why, and that the police are being called; keep everyone safe; use witnesses; keep the evidence; hand the person to the police and explain the reason; tell officers about witnesses, CCTV and recovered goods; and record the arrest. Ring 999. Avon and Somerset Police say to call 999 if the suspect is detained.
Is a citizen's arrest different in Scotland?
Yes. Section 24A applies to England and Wales only. In Scotland theft is a common-law crime, which the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service defines as "the appropriation of property belonging to another person without their consent", and the power of citizen's arrest comes from the common law too.
The test is stricter. Citizens Advice Scotland says the crime would have to be more serious than a breach of the peace, and "You would have to be sure that a crime had actually been committed, for example, by witnessing it or being the victim." Reasonable suspicion, which is enough in England while the theft is happening, is not the Scottish test. Citizens Advice Scotland also warns that a wrongful arrest can lead to a claim for financial compensation. Reasonable force may be used if the person resists, and they must be handed to the police as soon as possible. In a shop, that favours staff who saw the theft themselves over someone acting on a description passed over the radio.
Can a shop search a shoplifter's bag?
Not without their consent. In England and Wales the power to search someone after an arrest belongs to a police officer, under section 32 of PACE. The SIA's guidance says even a licensed door supervisor may only put their hands into a bag once "the individual has given their consent for the search to take place". Staff can ask to look in a bag. If the answer is no, the safe course anywhere in Great Britain is to note what you saw, keep the footage and let the police deal with it.
How do you report a shoplifter to the police?
In England and Wales, ring 999 if the theft is happening now, someone is in danger or the suspect is being held. Otherwise report on 101 or online. The NBCC's Theft From Shops guide points to police.uk, and Cleveland Police suggest online reporting because it is quicker than 101. Online forms such as Avon and Somerset Police's give you a crime reference number and, where it applies, instructions for sending CCTV.
In Scotland, Police Scotland has its own online form for shoplifting. Call 999 if someone is in danger, it is happening now or the suspect is still there. Call 101 instead of using the form if the incident involved another offence, such as threats or assaults on staff, or if someone involved may be under 12.
Cleveland Police's toolkit lists what helps the police most: a clear description of the offender, any vehicle details, witnesses, the value of the loss, the CCTV, whether they are a repeat offender, and the impact on staff and the business. It also suggests a Business Impact Statement, which records financial loss, the effect on staff wellbeing, extra security costs and the impact on customers, and can support court outcomes. Report every theft, even small ones: the NBCC says reports are how police learn the scale of the problem and where to put resources. If your shop belongs to a Business Crime Reduction Partnership, report to them as well.
Save the footage straight away, before the recorder overwrites it. We go through doing it in a format the police can use in how to export CCTV footage for the police, and how long recordings normally last in how long businesses keep CCTV footage.
What should staff write down afterwards?
Write it down while it is fresh, in a log every member of staff knows about. Taken from the police checklists above, a useful entry covers:
- The date, time and where in the shop it happened.
- What was seen, by whom, and the names of any witnesses.
- A description of the person and any vehicle.
- The items taken, their value, and anything recovered (keep recovered goods as they are).
- Anything said, any threats or force, and whether anyone was hurt.
- The police reference number, and which camera and time the footage is saved from.
That log is what supports a banning notice, a civil recovery claim and a Business Impact Statement later. If an arrest was made, the SIA says to record it in line with local policy and be ready to give the police a statement.
Can a shop ban a shoplifter?
Yes. The NBCC says "You are within your rights to ban anyone from your shop if you believe they have stolen, or pose a risk of stealing from your premises." The best way is in writing. Cleveland Police's toolkit includes a template Private Banning Notice, which should give the person's name if known, the premises covered, the reason, the start date, how long it lasts and what happens if they come back. Keep a copy, record when it was issued, and make sure every member of staff knows who is banned.
A ban has limits. Cleveland Police are plain that "A breach of a Private Banning Notice alone is not normally a criminal offence." If a banned person comes back, ask them to leave, do not put staff at risk, record it, keep the CCTV, and call the police if there are offences, threats, violence or disorder.
Shops can also ban together. A Business Crime Reduction Partnership (BCRP) is a local scheme where businesses share information in real time, often over a radio network and intelligence software, and many run an exclusion scheme described by the NBCC as "banned from one, banned from all". The NBCC says a BCRP must be registered with the ICO and work under information sharing agreements with police and businesses, because sharing who is banned means sharing personal data. Pubs and bars have their own local Pubwatch schemes, supported by National Pubwatch. Before you put a photo of a shoplifter on the wall or online, read can shops share photos of shoplifters.
What is civil recovery, and what are its limits?
Civil recovery is the shop claiming its losses and costs from the person, as a civil debt rather than a criminal penalty. Cleveland Police describe it as a process that "may allow businesses to seek recovery of losses and costs resulting from criminal conduct", and note it may be pursued in some circumstances even where there is no conviction. The person gets a letter, usually called a civil recovery letter, saying they have to pay.
According to Citizens Advice, a business can claim the value of what was stolen, the cost of staff investigating it and other costs such as security. The limits matter to a shop thinking of using it:
- Staff, administration and security costs must be proved for that incident. A business "can't claim fixed costs for these".
- If the person does not pay, the only way to get the money is a claim in the County Court, or the Sheriff Court in Scotland, and the business can only be paid if it proves in court that it is entitled to it.
- The civil standard of proof is lower than the criminal one, Citizens Advice Scotland notes, but you still need evidence: Cleveland Police list CCTV, witness evidence, incident reports and proof of losses.
Cleveland Police advise taking independent legal advice or using a recognised civil recovery provider before starting. Civil recovery sits alongside reporting to the police, not instead of it.
How does CCTV help after a theft?
Almost every option above runs on evidence, and in a shop most of that evidence is footage. The NBCC advises good quality CCTV that covers the whole store, regular checks that changing layouts have not blocked a camera, staff trained to download and share the images with police, and signs telling everyone CCTV is in use. An independent retailer in Glasgow, quoted in the ACS's 2025 guidance, put it simply: "The footage from the CCTV cameras is very useful when reporting crimes to the police."
Cameras will not stop every theft, and we set out the honest evidence in does CCTV stop shoplifting and the wider picture in shoplifting in the UK. What they do is turn "someone took a bottle of gin" into a face, a time and a direction for the police, a reason for a ban and the proof a civil claim needs. For where the cameras should go, see how many CCTV cameras a small shop needs and our guide to CCTV for shops.
The Ubiquiti UniFi systems we install record to a recorder in your own shop, with no subscription, so the clip is on site when the police ask for it. Get a quote for shop CCTV, tell us how the shop is laid out, and we will suggest where cameras need to go to catch faces at the door and hands at the till.
Last reviewed 8 November 2026.